Here’s a transcript from a Facebook conversation between one of my friends and me regarding “proof” of God’s existence and reasons that we could provide for why someone should become a Christian.
Thought I’d share them with you.
7:47pm Jim …. Dr. Blakemore!
7:47pm Steve …. Jimbo!
7:48pm Jim …. hey buddy. you staying out of trouble?
7:48pm Steve ….I am getting to old for trouble.
7:48pm Jim ….Let me ask you a question…
7:48pm Steve ….Ok
7:49pm Jim ….
If a non believer came up to you and asked, “Why should I become a Christian?” what would you say. Secondly, in your mind, “What is the greatest proof that God exists?”
7:50pm Steve ….Yikes! glad I did not know what question you wanted to ask.
7:50pm Jim …. well??
7:52pm Steve ….
Second one first. To me the greatest single evidence that God exists is the fact of human consciousness, human drive for purpose and the moral impulse that is inescapable for us. The naturalistic explanations for these things are at their weakest. To explain the moral impulse, for instance, naturalists have to end up redefining morality in a way that undoes the moral impulse that they feel.
[UPDATE--Not in the original conversation] The naturalistic explanation that denies God as the source of our moral intuition has been discussed thoroughly by C. S. Lewis in “Mere Christianity” and more recently by Francis Collins in his book “The Language of God.”
7:53pm Jim …. ok…I think I’m with ya. You want to know what Billy Grahams answer was?
7:53pm Steve …. Sure
7:54pm Jim ….
The reporter, Frost asked him that very same question years ago. I saw it on T.V. I’ll never forget the answer. He said, “I cannot prove there is a God…but the greatest proof there is that there is a God is the order in the universe and the miracle of birth.”
7:56pm Jim …. But dude, yours is far more “philosophical”. heh heh.Ok…so what about the first question?
8:00pm Steve ….
The first. Well, I would ask the unbeliever about the meaning that he or she thought his or her life had.Then I would engage them in a discussion in which I would inquire whether or not they believed that God cares for them.
If they said yes, I’d say how do you know.
At that point I would point to the Resurrection of Jesus Christ as a historical event that should be taken seriously. And suggest to them that they should explore the Christian claims that the Resurrection is proof of God’s love for them and the world.
8:03pm Steve ….
If he were interested, I’d suggest that the Christian faith can help him understand his own existence more deeply and clearly than any other explanation he could ever entertain.
8:04pm Steve ….
At that point I would say, If Jesus really did rise from the dead and he really was telling the truth when he said he would die for the sins of us all and that his own presence was evidence of God’s love for the world, then the person should place faith in him and become a Christian.
That’s the best I can do on FB and on the fly!!!!!!!!
8:05pm Jim ….
Somewhere in there you may have to give validity to Scripture as the word of God.But then again, the Bible holds its own… we don’t have to “Prove” the Bible in my estimation.
Its words have enough conviction in them don’t you think?
8:06pm Steve ….
Well, the truest validity of scripture is rooted in Jesus. His resurrection is the validation. It is the best explanation for the existence of the church and the existence of the church’s writings about him
Also, I do agree with you that the Spirit will make the scripture adequate for those who are truly hungry for meaning and truth.
8:08pm Jim …. true, however, we have to admit, the Scriptures speak of Christ, but what if a guy doesn’t believe the Scriptures.
8:11pm Steve ….
If a guy does not believe the scriptural witness, I want to know why not. If he believes that Socrates, for example, is a real person, then I simply point out to him that the only evidence we have that Socrates was real is found in the writings of his disciples, Plato and others.
Also, I would point out that we have Way more textual evidence for Jesus than we do for Socrates.
8:13pm Steve ….
Then I would suggest that he has already made up his mind about the truth of the scripture ahead of time for reasons other than his stated objections. And I would ask him why he has decided the case prematurely. And suggest that he needed to be more open and questioning about truth.
Blessings, bro.